ON CLIENTS & PITCHES
Bite-size: Marketing changes attitudes, but some attitudes are harder to change than others. Preferences toward a brand, for example, are flexible (e.g., positive or negative associations), but attitudes formed along moral lines are much more rigid, treating issues as a matter of universal right vs. wrong (Skitka et al., 2005).
Full-size:
When we think about attitudes, we often simplify them to likes and dislikes. Preferences, like positive or negative associations made during experiences and formed as memories, are flexible and often what marketing targets. But social norms—opinions from friends and family, or rules we follow as a society—also inform our attitudes. These social conventions can be a bit more difficult to affect. Moral convictions, however, are uncompromising (Skitka et al., 2005, 2008).
Compared to other constructs, attitudes that reflect moral beliefs are experienced as “objectively and universally true” and “inherently more motivating and self-justifying” than non-moral attitudes (Skitka et al., 2005). This makes people with strong moral convictions steadfast and inflexible in their beliefs, with no actual proof required (think staunch vaccine disbelievers when presented with scientific evidence).
Moral Foundations Theory (Graham et al., 2013; Haidt & Joseph, 2004) posits that morally rooted attitudes derive their strength from underlying intuitive moral codes—such as liberty, care, or loyalty—making people equally invested emotionally and morally. Research further demonstrates that those acting from moral conviction tend to be more intolerant of change and defensive of their position.
Marketers can overcome this using moral reframing (Feinberg & Willer, 2015, 2019). Framing a position to appeal directly to someone's underlying moral values—even if they would not normally support the proposal—is a scientifically validated technique for persuasive communication.
Example: Consider a person who opposes vaccines because they believe government mandates violate their personal liberty and autonomy. Because their conviction is morally rooted, scientific evidence alone is rarely persuasive. By reframing the pro-vaccine message around liberty (e.g., framing vaccination as a way to preserve freedom and defeating COVID-19 as the true enemy of personal freedom), the message challenges the attitude by appealing directly to their core moral foundation (Feinberg & Willer, 2015; Voelkel & Feinberg, 2017).