ON BRANDS & ADVERTISING
Bite-size: When we believe something took effort to make, we value it more. When we can’t judge quality directly, effort is the shortcut we use. Brands can show the work to raise perceived value, or hide it to make a service feel effortless. The skill is knowing which moments call for which.
Full-size:
In 2004, Justin Kruger and colleagues showed people the same poem, the same painting, the same suit of armor. Half were told it took the maker a short time; half were told it took much longer. The “longer” version was rated higher in quality and worth more money every time. The effect was strongest when people had no other way to judge quality. That’s the effort heuristic: hard work reads as high worth.
Ryan Buell and Michael Norton found the same thing in services. People using a travel search site valued it more when they could watch it work, listing each airline as it searched, than when results appeared instantly. They even preferred the slower version. Seeing the labor made the result feel worth more.
Showing the work
Domino’s Pizza Tracker walks you through “Prep,” “Bake,” “Quality Check” and “Out for Delivery.” Whether or not each stage updates in real time is beside the point. The tracker turns a wait into visible effort, and visible effort reads as care.
Lush puts a round sticker on every soap and bath bomb with the name and face of the person who made it and the date they made it. One glance says a human labored over this. It moves a bar of soap toward gift territory before it leaves the shelf.
Hiding the work
The opposite move is to remove all visible effort so a service feels like magic. Apple’s Express Transit mode is the clean example: no Face ID, no unlocking, one tap and the gate opens. Everything that makes it secure is buried under a single beep.
Amazon’s “Just Walk Out” stores promised the same thing for groceries. The effort behind it was larger than it looked. The Information reported that as of 2022, more than a thousand workers in India supported the system, mostly labeling training data and reviewing some transactions. Amazon disputed the framing and said humans checked only a small share of visits. Either way, in April 2024 Amazon pulled the system from its large Fresh stores in favor of smart carts that show a running total. Hiding effort is expensive, and when the hidden effort comes out, it reads as a trick rather than as craft.
That’s the line to watch. Hidden complexity is fine. Hidden labor that customers would object to is a trust problem waiting to surface.
How to use it
Map the moments. Where does visible effort reassure (preparation, packaging, anything the customer is waiting for)? Where is speed the whole point? Treat them differently.
Show real effort. A progress display or a maker’s name works because the effort behind it exists. Staged effort that gets exposed costs more than it earned.
Hide complexity, not labor. Burying the engineering is design. Burying people is a liability.
Check it still lands. Craft cues wear out. Ask whether your effort signal still means something to this year’s customer.
Effort is a lever. Show it when you need “made with care.” Remove it when effortless is the promise. Decide on purpose.
Sources
Kruger, J., Wirtz, D., Van Boven, L., & Altermatt, T. W. (2004). The effort heuristic. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 40(1).
Buell, R. W., & Norton, M. I. (2011). The labor illusion: How operational transparency increases perceived value. Management Science, 57(9).
Norton, M. I., Mochon, D., & Ariely, D. (2012). The IKEA effect. Journal of Consumer Psychology, 22(3).
The Information (April 2024), reporting on Just Walk Out; Amazon’s response, via subsequent coverage.